Comp Picks?

[Packers GM (Wood)]

Type A:

Ranked 1-5 QB in the previous season
Ranked 1-10 RB in the previous season
Ranked 1-10 WR in the previous season
Ranked 1-5 TE in the previous season
Ranked 1-2 DT in the previous season
Ranked 1-5 DE in the previous season
Ranked 1-5 LB in the previous season
Ranked 1-5 CB in the previous season
Ranked 1-5 S in the previous season

Type B:

Ranked 6-10 QB in the previous season
Ranked 11-15 RB in the previous season
Ranked 11-15 WR in the previous season
Ranked 6-10 TE in the previous season
Ranked 3-4 DT in the previous season
Ranked 6-10 DE in the previous season
Ranked 6-10 LB in the previous season
Ranked 6-10 CB in the previous season
Ranked 6-10 S in the previous season

went thru and did a little more adjusting, this would be and example.

"There is no limit to what can be accomplished when nobody cares who gets the credit."

[Bengals GM (David)]

I never liked putting back the Type B comp picks. But if you truly insist again we should have the Top 10%, rounded up to the nearest 5 for ease, of startable players get comp. But move the less valuable IDPs of DT, CB, SF to the Type B category.

A:

QB 1-5
RB 1-10
WR 1-10
TE 1-5
DE 1-10
LB 1-10

B:

DT 1-5
CB 1-10
SF 1-10


2015 Comps Redone:

6 1st Round Comps: Cobb, Houston, Forsett, Smith, Harris, Hughes.
7 2nd Round Comps: Woodson, Mundy, Adams, Haden, Skrine, Fletcher, Williams.

[Packers GM (Wood)]

SF?

"There is no limit to what can be accomplished when nobody cares who gets the credit."

[Bengals GM (David)]

Safeties.

[Packers GM (Wood)]

ok, i thought so but wanted to double check.

Yours looks pretty good.

"There is no limit to what can be accomplished when nobody cares who gets the credit."

[Raiders GM (Dylan)]

I like Dave's proposal. I also wouldn't mind giving a comp A picks to the top 10 QBS just because it so hard to get a decent one in this big of a league.